From Side Hustle to Full-Time Business: How I Built a Successful Shirt Shop on Etsy

My Journey From Screen Printing in My Garage to Running a Thriving E-Commerce Store

As an artist and designer, I’ve always loved expressing my creativity through apparel. So when I lost my 9 to 5 job a few years ago, I decided to turn my screen printing hobby into a side business making and selling shirts online.

Flash forward to today, and that little Etsy shop is now my full-time gig! In just a couple years, I’ve gone from printing shirts in my garage and fulfilling orders in the evenings, to running a complete e-commerce operation that supports my family.

And while it certainly hasn’t been easy, building my shirt business on Etsy has been an incredibly rewarding experience. Not only do I get to do what I love every day, but I’ve built valuable skills in marketing, branding, customer service, and of course making quality products that people love.

So if you’re thinking about starting a t-shirt business on Etsy, I want to share my story to help you set up for success. In this post, I’ll take you through everything I’ve learned, from how to get started on Etsy to growing a loyal customer base and making the jump to full-time entrepreneur. Let’s dive in!

Getting Started: What You Need to Sell Shirts on Etsy

If you’re ready to start designing shirts and getting your work in front of customers, here’s what you need to begin:

An Etsy Shop– Setting up your shop is fast and easy. You can choose a unique shop name, create branding for your shop banner and logo, and write compelling shop policies to establish your business.

High-Quality Shirt Designs– Great designs are at the core of every successful shirt shop. Spend time honing your aesthetic and crafting designs with popular appeal. Consider trends but also add your unique creative flair.

Printing Equipment & Supplies– To make your designs physical, you’ll need a way to print them on shirts. Look into screen printing, heat transfer vinyl, or direct-to-garment printing to get started. Buy blank shirt stock in a variety of colors and sizes.

Photography Skills– Take clear, well-lit photos of your shirts on models. Good photos drive sales and set your listings apart. Invest in a lighting kit, mannequins, and photo editing software like Photoshop.

Packaging Materials– To ship orders, stock up on poly mailers, tissue paper, stickers, thank you cards – all the extras that make receiving a package fun. Quality packaging increases reviews and repeat business.

With these core elements in place, you’re ready to start creating listings and making sales! Now let’s talk best practices as you grow your Etsy shop.

Crafting Stand-Out Listings: Tips for Success

One of the most important parts of running an Etsy shop is writing compelling product listings. Here are my top tips for making listings that convert:

Choose descriptive titles– Titles should be clear about the shirt style, color, and design. Include important keywords that buyers would search for.

Write detailed descriptions– Elaborate on the shirt’s features, materials, care instructions, and your printing process. Share your brand story and why the design is special.

Maximize tags– Include all relevant keywords in your tags. This helps get your listings found in Etsy search results.

Highlight variations– If offering multiple colors, sizes, or sleeve lengths, use the variations feature to showcase what’s available.

Stage excellent photos– Thoroughly read Etsy’s photography tips. Shoot shirts on models against simple backgrounds. Include close-ups of design details.

Optimize for mobile– Most shoppers browse Etsy on their phones. Ensure photos and text display well on mobile screens.

Promote policies– Share shipping timelines, domestic and international options, returns, and care instructions. This builds trust with buyers.

Add personality– Let your brand’s voice shine through. Share your creative process and story behind each design.

Following Etsy’s best practices takes a little extra work, but it pays off with more clicks, favorites, and sales!

Pricing Your Shirts for Maximum Profit

Determining how much to charge for your shirts is an important balancing act. Price too high, and sales will be slow. Too low, and you won’t make sufficient profit. Follow these tips to find that sweet spot:

Calculate your costs– Add up the blanks, packaging, shipping, Etsy fees, and business expenses. Don’t forget your time invested in production.

Compare your competition– Do research to see what similar shirts sell for from other Etsy sellers, online boutiques, and retailers.

Consider perceived value– Factors like quality materials, unique designs, and brand reputation allow for higher prices.

Know your profit goals– Decide the minimum profit you want to make per shirt. Price with that target in mind.

Offer tiered pricing– Provide good/better/best product options at various price points. This attracts a wider range of buyers.

Run sales and promotions– Offer sitewide sales during peak seasons or discounts on bundled purchases to spur volume.

Adapt over time– Adjust pricing as your brand grows and production costs rise or fall. Use data to determine optimal prices.

There’s no one-size-fits-all formula, but starting out small and increasing prices as you build an audience is a solid strategy. Stick close to competitors’ prices until you become established as a premium brand.

Manufacturing vs Handmade: What Etsy’s Production Rules Allow

One key decision when starting a shirt shop on Etsy is whether to manufacture your shirts yourself or work with a production partner. Etsy has guidelines around this that are important to understand:

“Handmade” items must be designed and physically made by you. Screen printing, heat press, and DTG printing fall into this category.

“Manufactured” items can be made by production partners, like overseas shirt printing shops, as long as you designed the artwork.

“Production partners” rules limit manufactured items to one partner per design. You must disclose details about the partner in each listing.

No reselling “mass produced” items – Dropshipping pre-made designs from Amazon or Alibaba is not allowed.

Transparency is key – Be open about your production methods in listings so customers understand who makes the shirts and how.

While handmaking shirts yourself allows you to list as “handmade”, partnering strategically with manufacturers provides opportunities to scale and increase profit margins. Just be sure to abide by Etsy’s rules as your business grows.

Optimizing for Etsy Search: How to Get Found in Results

Driving traffic to your Etsy listings from the site’s immense customer base is essential. With over 60 million buyers searching Etsy each month, there’s huge potential to get your shirts seen. But you have to optimize properly. Here are my top search engine optimization tips:

Include high-traffic keywords in your titles, tags, and descriptions. Research popular searches related to shirts so you can target those terms.

Refresh old listings to keep them appearing in results. Change up a sentence in the description or swap a product photo to get a renewed search boost.

Stay on top of trends and capitalize on seasonal keywords and viral styles. Around the holidays? Add “Christmas shirts” as a tag. Playing off a meme? Work the meme name into your title.

Choose specific tags like the shirt color and niche design style (eg: “dark humor”, “geeky”) rather than broad terms. The more precise the better for search.

Add bestsellers to Etsy Ads so they gain visibility in search results. Appearing in both organic results and ads means more impressions.

Optimize photos with alt text including your most important keywords. Images drive a lot of search on Etsy so photo SEO matters.

Include your shop name in titles so Etsy associates your branding with those shirt styles in search algorithms.

Refresh designs regularly to give customers fresh searches to discover rather than listing the same shirts for years.

Implementing these search strategies takes ongoing work, but it directly translates to more eyes on your product listings.

Marketing Your Shirts: Pinterest, Instagram, and Beyond

While Etsy itself is a powerful marketing channel, you can multiply your shop’s reach by tapping into other platforms. As you build your brand, be active on sites like:

Pinterest – Drive referral traffic by creating eye-catching product pin posts optimized with keywords. Share your designs in topical Pinterest boards with big followings.

Instagram – Post shop updates, beautiful lifestyle shots of your shirts, and behind-the-scenes of your process. Use compelling captions and strategic hashtags.

Facebook – Run Pinterest and Instagram ads to reach potential buyers who match your target audience. Leverage pixel tracking to retarget website visitors.

TikTok – Create fun, engaging video content around your brand and designs to resonate with the TikTok community. Add shop links to your bio and videos.

Twitter – Build connections in the art and t-shirt community. Share your newest releases and participate in Twitter chats relevant to your niche.

Email marketing – Collect subscriber emails through your website and Etsy. Send newsletters with sales, new arrivals, and special subscriber discounts.

Influencers – Gift free shirts to relevant bloggers, social media influencers, and celebrities. Getting your shirts featured organically on their accounts can drive massive interest.

The more platforms you’re actively using to promote your shop, the more potential buyers you can reach in targeted, cost-effective ways.

Order Fulfillment: Handling Shipping Like a Pro

When you make that exciting first Etsy sale, you need to be ready to ship orders quickly and professionally. Follow these tips for smooth order fulfillment:

Choose the right packaging – Poly mailers are affordable and protect shirts in transit. For a premium touch, use custom tissue paper and stickers with your logo.

Ship fast – Get orders out within your stated processing time (1-3 business days is ideal). Quick delivery gets you great reviews.

Send tracking info – Enter tracking numbers into Etsy so customers can follow their package. Send the number to the buyer directly too.

Use calculated shipping – Take advantage of Etsy’s calculated shipping profiles to display real rates automatically. It’s less work for you.

Offer free shipping – Absorb shipping costs into your product pricing. Free shipping incentivizes bigger purchases and saves you trips to the post office.

Master the post office – Establish relationships with staff at your local post office. Bring package prep supplies to streamline drop-offs.

Insure valuable orders – If shipping pricier custom orders, insure them in case of mail mishaps. It provides peace of mind.

The more orders you ship, the more efficient you’ll get at fulfillment. But strive for a wow factor from day one. Unexpected free gifts and handwritten notes show customers how much you appreciate their business!

Photographing Shirts: Styles, Poses, and Props

Your Etsy listings live and die by the photos. When someone is searching for the perfect t-shirt, your photos need to stylishly showcase the design. Use these photography tips I’ve picked up:

Shoot on models – Showing shirt designs being worn gives customers a realistic view of the fit. Have a range of models of different sizes.

Style it – Dress shirts up with accessories and layers like jackets, jewelry and hats to inspire customers and display versatility.

Pose models naturally – Have models engage with the camera, interact with props, turn different directions, walk, or look over the shoulder for dynamic shots.

Show off details – Do close-ups of unique design details, embellishments, and print textures. Different angles showcase the artwork fully.

Photograph flat – In addition to modeled shots, take some flattened pictures on a table or hanging on the wall to display the full designs.

Optimize lighting – Bright, diffused natural light is best. Invest in professional lighting like soft box lights if needed. Avoid shadows.

Use solid color backgrounds – Light gray, white, and black backgrounds keep focus on the shirt rather than busy patterns.

Edit for clarity – Adjust brightness, contrast, cropping, and colors to make designs really stand out in photos.

Capturing your shirts’ unique details, quality, and style makes listings irresistible. Customers want to see themselves wearing your clever, artistic designs.

Offering Customization: Printing Personalized Tees

In addition to pre-designed shirts, consider offering personalized and custom printing. Many Etsy buyers love getting one-of-a-kind products tailored just for them. Here are tips on providing customization:

Print names, phrases – Let customers submit a name, date, or custom saying to add to your designs. Great for family shirts and gifts.

Do complete custom designs – Work with buyers directly to design shirts around their requests, ideas, and interests from scratch.

Guide the process – Provide design templates, fonts, clip art options and clear instructions to simplify creating custom orders.

Set proper pricing – Charge more for custom orders to compensate for the extra time communicating, designing, and printing individually.

Set order limits – Start slowly by only accepting a couple custom orders per week until you perfect systems to handle increased volume.

Communicate timelines – Give accurate turnaround times so customers know when to expect custom pieces to arrive. Underpromise and overdeliver.

Limit revisions – Be transparent about how many back-and-forth version tweaks you’ll allow to keep projects moving.

Get approval before final printing – Share digital mockups for approval so no surprises at final delivery.

Custom orders allow you to provide a specialized experience, charge more, and build lasting relationships with Etsy customers.

Avoiding Common Mistakes for Etsy Shirt Sellers

Starting a new business comes with growing pains. As you build your Etsy shop, be aware of these common mistakes to avoid:

Low quality photography – Blurry, dark pictures scream amateur. Invest in quality photo equipment and lighting to showcase products.

Spam tagging – Don’t keyword stuff listings trying to cheat the search algorithm. Use tags naturally.

No policies – Failing to post policies on shipping, returns, exchanges, etc. causes buyer confusion down the line.

Ignoring best practices – Cutting corners on descriptions, tagging, and optimizing for search hurts your visibility. Do it right.

Listening to critics – Not everyone will like your designs. Believe in your work and don’t lose yourself trying to please critics.

Too few designs – Don’t wait for perfect. List new designs frequently to keep shoppers engaged and coming back.

Manual order processing – Let Etsy and other apps do the work for you. Automate and outsource to save time.

Disorganized workflow – Sloppy processes kill productivity. Map out systems so you can efficiently order supplies, design, print, photograph, list, ship, etc.

Learning from mistakes will help your Etsy shop improve over time. But avoiding obvious pitfalls from the start lets you build solid business practices.

Managing Inventory for Your Etsy Shop

Keeping shirts in stock for fulfilling orders is crucial for success. Run out of inventory too often and you’ll disappoint buyers. Manage your stock with these tips:

Track inventory – Use Etsy’s built-in inventory management system or another tool to update counts as items sell. Link listings so options update across color/size variations.

Order conservatively – Don’t buy huge shirt stock minimums as you’re starting out. Opt for smaller reorder amounts until sales pick up.

Print backup stock – For proven top selling designs, always have 5-10 shirts printed and on-hand for when you sell out.

Offer pre-orders – If a popular shirt is sold out, take pre-orders so customers can still purchase and reserve an upcoming restock.

Plan seasonally – Replenish basics before busy seasons like holidays. Stock trendy shirts capitalizing on viral memes and pop culture while they’re hot.

Remove sold out listings – Take down unavailable products so customers don’t get frustrated seeing items marked sold out for long periods.

Segment fabric buys – Order fabric specifically for customs/made-to-order items separately from bulk blank shirts for core designs.

Forecast demand – Review past sales data to estimate future demand. Leave wiggle room for unpredictable viral hits.

Staying on top of your supply chain means no missed sales opportunities and production delays.

Handling Customer Service on Etsy

Providing 5-star customer service sets your shop apart on Etsy’s competitive marketplace. Here are my top strategies for customer satisfaction:

Quick communication – Answer convos and messages within 24 hours. Set up email and message automation to respond instantly with common questions.

Resolve issues – If a customer has a problem with an order, refund/replace it without hassle. Turn complaints into positive experiences.

Thanks for reviews – Always respond to reviews thanking the customer. Ask for feedback on how you can improve too.

Surprise freebies – Toss in a freebie sticker or print with each order. Small gifts excite customers.

Check production quality – Carefully inspect shirts before shipping to catch issues. Customers shouldn’t receive flawed or incorrect items.

Follow up – Check in with buyers a week after delivery to see if they’re still delighted with their purchase.

Gather feedback – Run occasional sales offering discounts for leaving a review to get more customer opinions.

Stay friendly – Even dealing with difficult customers, remain calm and kill with kindness. Your reputation is everything.

Going the extra mile to provide awesome support makes loyal customers who will purchase from your shop again and again.

Promoting Your Shop with Etsy Ads

As an Etsy seller, you have access to the site’s powerful advertising platform. With the right strategy, Etsy ads can help sales skyrocket. Here are tips to maximize your ad success:

Start small – Allocate a modest daily budget like $1-2 per day when first launching ads. Adjust up slowly and watch ROI.

Perfect listings first – Optimize your shop and listings completely before investing in ads. That way you convert traffic optimally.

Target top sellers – Promote your proven best selling, 5-star review shirts that you know customers love. Newly listed designs are riskier.

Retarget engaged visitors – Use the Etsy pixel to serve ads to people who have already visited your shop and show interest.

Focus locally – Target buyers by country and customize ads with local verbiage, prices, and shipping options. Language and cultural personalization matter.

Try Different ad types – Experiment with display, promoted listings, shopping ads, and Offsite ads to see which convert best for your products.

Master keywords – Research and test niche keywords that attract customers seeking specific shirt styles, themes, and occasions.

Monitor analytics – Use Etsy’s reporting to see which keywords, listings, and audiences generate the most clicks and sales. Double down on what works.

Optimize for conversions – Write compelling headlines and test ad creative to inspire high click-through-rates and push viewers to purchase.

With time and tweaking, Etsy ads can become your most powerful sales tool, connecting your shirts with buyers all over the world.

Sourcing Ethically: People and Planet-Friendly Printing

On Etsy, shoppers expect handmade goods produced in socially and environmentally responsible ways. As your shirt business grows, commit to ethical and sustainable practices like:

Using organic cotton – Choose blanks made from organic rather than conventional cotton which uses more chemical pesticides and water in farming.

Printing eco-friendly inks – Switch from plastisol to water-based inks. Avoid hazardous chemicals; properly dispose of ink.

Partnering thoughtfully – Thoroughly vet production partners for fair labor practices. Favor local businesses over offshore sweatshops.

Reducing waste – Run optimized print batches to minimize unused shirt yards and misprints. Recycle used blank swatches for stuffing packaging.

Reusing packaging – Opt for recyclable poly mailers and repurpose received shipments. Buy recycled paper, boxes, and void fill.

Conserving resources – Use energy and water efficiently in your print shop. Move toward solar power and greater sustainability.

Giving back – Donate a portion of profits or surplus apparel to charities. Sponsor donations when customers purchase.

Educating buyers – Communicate your values and processes openly so customers understand the care behind your brand.

Making people and planet a priority earns buyer trust and loyalty. Advertise your commitment to ethics.

Managing Returns and Exchanges

Despite your best efforts, returns and exchanges are inevitable. Make the process painless for customers by:

Accepting all returns – Take back any shirt for any reason with quick refunds, no questions asked (within reason of course).

Providing pre-paid return labels – Send customers a return label with original shipment for easy sending back if needed.

Offering exchanges – Let customers exchange for a different size or color at no charge so you keep the sale.

Allowing try-on – Give a few days for customers to ensure fit and styling are right before wearing the shirt.

Stating policies upfront – List return timeline/windows and conditions clearly in listings, shops policies, and packaging so no surprises.

Reminding gently – If shirts are customized or printed on demand, remind customers they are non-refundable when ordering.

Following up politely – When you receive a returned shirt, reach out to ask why and improve based on feedback.

Repurposing returns – Lightly worn returns can be donated or resold as “open box” items on sale.

Your return policy reassures buyers that shopping at your Etsy shop is risk-free. Taking losses protects long-term relationships.

Riding Seasonal and Trend Waves

Etsy shopping patterns change based on seasons, holidays, and timely trends. Adjust your shirts to capitalize on shifts in demand throughout the year.

Holiday designs – Around major holidays like Christmas and Halloween, introduce festive shirt designs using popular seasonal themes. Time listings for peak demand.

Back to school – From late summer through September, school-related shirts and college themes are hot sellers. List shirts for students of all ages.

Summer styles – In warm months, design tank tops, short sleeve tees, and breathable shirts in bright colors and vacation themes.

Valentine’s ideas – Romantic, funny, and couple shirts for Valentine’s day attract winter sales. Share gift listing links on social media for easy sharing.

Sales seasons – Run promotions with discounted shirts around peak seasons like back to school, holidays, and the new year for a sales lift.

Timely trends – Ride memes, pop culture news, celebrity moments, and viral stories with fun, timely designs while trends are hot.

Evergreen basics – Balance fads and holidays with classic, timeless designs and shirt styles that maintain year-round appeal.

Riding the waves of seasonal shopping and timely trends keeps your inventory and inspiration fresh all year long.

Getting Customer Feedback to Improve

While growing my Etsy shop, customer feedback has been invaluable. It helps me constantly strengthen my shirt business and exceed buyer expectations. Here’s how I collect it:

Product reviews – Always politely ask happy customers to leave an honest review of their purchase experience. The more data the better.

Shops sections – Add shop sections with customer photos and testimonials. Positive social proof builds trust and reputation.

Email follow-ups – A week after delivery, email buyers asking how they’re enjoying the shirt and if they have any suggestions.

Social media polls – Run quick polls on social channels asking what styles and themes customers want to see next.

Give perks – Offer a small discount on their next order for customers who fill out a short feedback survey. Incentivizes quality responses.

Note complaints – If customers express dissatisfaction, dig into the root causes so you can continue improving.

Monitor reviews – Stay on top of your overall shop reviews and quickly address any emerging issues or bugs affecting multiple buyers.

Take action – Actually implement feedback in your production process, website, customer service, listing practices, etc. Show customers their voice matters.

Proactively seeking input cuts down on negative reviews and helps refine your Etsy shop for success. Customers guide your biz in the right direction!

Legal Tips for Etsy Sellers: Taxes, Insurance, and More

Congratulations, your Etsy shop is thriving! As you scale, be sure you understand the legal elements involved in running an apparel business.

Register business name – Depending on location, establish a LLC or other official business structure. Protect your brand name.

Get seller’s permit – Obtain a permit/license to collect sales tax in your state and charge customers appropriately at checkout.

Understand product liability – Know shirts aren’t FDA regulated. Use caution marketing medical/safety claims and properly disclose risks like choking hazards for children.

Mind IP rules – Don’t infringe on trademarks, licensed logos, or copyrighted pop culture content with shirt designs unless licensed. Get permission when needed.

Buy insurance – Insure business property against theft/damage. Purchase liability insurance to protect against customer injury lawsuits. Better safe than sued!

File taxes – Keep immaculate records and pay all owed income taxes, 1099s, quarterly estimated taxes, and self-employment tax.

Comply with regulations – Follow CPSIA product safety rules, FTC guidelines, CPSC toy standards, and other relevant regulations.

Terms of Service – Read and understand Etsy’s Terms of Use. Follow their fee structures, policies, and restrictions carefully to avoid account suspension.

I know legal stuff isn’t glamorous, but covering these bases allows you to operate transparently while fully focused on your creative pursuits. Protect your passion!

Ready to Start Your Own Etsy Shirt Shop?

If you made it this far, hopefully you feel equipped and inspired to start selling shirts on Etsy! Of course building any business takes immense work, but I firmly believe Etsy provides one of the most rewarding and creative entrepreneurial opportunities out there today.

So carve out time for your shop each day, even if just an hour at first. Learn as you go. Persevere through challenges. Stay true to your brand vision. And most importantly, keep creating amazing shirts you believe in.

The sense of pride and freedom that comes from turning your passion into a full-time small business is life-changing. I can’t wait to see the unique, awesome shirts you’ll dream up!

If you have any other questions about getting started on Etsy or managing a print on demand apparel business, please reach out anytime. I’m always happy to chat shop and help fellow artists and makers!

Now get out there, design some super cool shirts, and start selling! Wishing you huge success on your Etsy journey. You got this!



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *